Nearly 2 in 3 Online Shoppers Say Waiting on a Refund Causes Financial Stress, New Seel Research Finds

PR Newswire

As refund delays test shopper trust this holiday season, 81% say a retailer’s return policy can decide where they buy

SAN FRANCISCO, Nov. 19, 2026 /PRNewswire/ — Nearly two-thirds of U.S. online shoppers (63%) say waiting for a retailer to receive their return before issuing a refund creates financial stress for them, according to new research released today by Seel, the AI-native commerce platform helping merchants run post-purchase operations end to end.

Seel

The 2027 Holiday Shopping Trust Outlook, which was conducted by The Harris Poll on Seel’s behalf and surveyed more than 1,900 U.S. adults who have shopped online in the past six months (referred to as online shoppers throughout), comes as household budgets remain stretched heading into the holidays. Two in three U.S. adults live paycheck to paycheck, according to PYMNTS Intelligence, and U.S. shoppers were projected to return $849.9 billion in merchandise in 2025, according to the National Retail Federation and Happy Returns. Seel’s survey suggests many shoppers are counting on the refunds from those returns. Eighty-seven percent say that given the current economy, it is especially important to know they can return an online purchase and get a full refund.

Key highlights include:

  • Refund delays are hitting budgets. Nearly two-thirds of online shoppers (63%) say waiting for a retailer to receive their return before issuing a refund causes them financial stress. That rises to 77% among both 18- to 34-year-olds and parents of children under 18, and to 74% among households earning under $50,000.
  • Some younger shoppers return items to pay bills. 16% of 18- to 34-year-old online shoppers say they have returned an online purchase in the past year because they needed the money back to cover bills or other expenses.
  • Return costs keep unwanted items at home. 63% of online shoppers have kept an unwanted online purchase because returning it cost too much, including 75% of parents of children under 18.

“Trust is the foundation of e-commerce, and much of it is decided after checkout,” said Zack Peng, CEO of Seel. “A shopper pays upfront and counts on the retailer to hold up its end if something goes wrong. When a refund takes weeks to arrive, the retailer loses that trust. Retailers that make refunds fast and certain give shoppers a reason to come back.”

Shoppers are also holding back from retailers. Nearly half of online shoppers (47%) say they have given a retailer a different reason for a return than the actual one, including 62% of 18- to 34-year-olds. Asked about the actual reasons behind returns they made in the past year (regardless of what they told the retailer), online shoppers most often cited an item that didn’t fit (26%), arrived damaged or defective (22%) or didn’t match its description (22%). Others pointed to reasons a retailer is unlikely to hear: 12% returned an impulse purchase, 10% regretted spending the money and 9% needed the money back to cover bills or other expenses. Across hundreds of billions of dollars in returns each year, that gap can leave retailers making sizing, inventory and policy decisions on incomplete information.

“For a lot of households right now, a refund is part of the monthly budget,” said Laura Huddle, Chief Revenue Officer at Seel. “When someone sends back a jacket in January, that money may already be set aside for rent or a credit card bill. Every day it sits in a return queue is a day that family is short. Most return policies were written before shoppers needed their money back this fast.”

Trust is also shaping holiday gift shopping. Eight in 10 online shoppers (80%) say they would hesitate to buy a gift online this season. The most common concern is buying from a website they’ve never purchased from before because it’s the only place the item is available (35%). Next are the recipient having to pay for return shipping if they needed to make a return (26%) and not being sure an item bought early could be returned after the holidays (24%). Eighty-three percent of online shoppers would be more likely to buy a gift online if they were certain it could be returned after the holidays, even without the original receipt.

Online shoppers say they are willing to pay for that certainty. Six in 10 (61%) would be likely to pay a small additional fee at checkout for a worry-free return option with free return shipping and a guaranteed refund on an eligible purchase, rising to 77% among 18- to 34-year-olds.

“Most retailers still treat refund timing as a back-office detail, but for shoppers it’s part of the purchase decision,” added Huddle. “During the holidays, that decision happens at checkout, before a single return is made. The retailers that give shoppers confidence they’ll get their money back will see it in conversion now and in repeat purchases long after the season ends.”

For more information about the research, visit: https://www.seel.com/holiday-trust-report  

About Seel
Seel is an AI-powered ecommerce platform that helps merchants simplify and scale their operations. It brings together returns, shipping protection, warranties, customer support and resale with Seel’s AI Workforce, a set of AI Agencies that manage commerce workflows end to end and deliver business outcomes alongside merchants’ existing teams. By replacing disconnected tools and vendors with one integrated system, Seel helps merchants improve the customer experience while operating more efficiently.

Methodology:
This survey was conducted online within the United States by The Harris Poll on behalf of Seel from October 22 – 24, 2026 among 1,921 adults ages 18 and older who have shopped online in the past 6 months. The sampling precision of Harris online polls is measured by using a Bayesian credible interval. For this study, the sample data is accurate to within +/- 2.7 percentage points using a 95% confidence level. For complete survey methodology, including weighting variables and subgroup sample sizes, please contact seel@bambybig.agency.

Cision View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/nearly-2-in-3-online-shoppers-say-waiting-on-a-refund-causes-financial-stress-new-seel-research-finds-302945693.html

SOURCE Seel Inc.

About The Author